Our Identity In Christ
SHOW NOTES
What if the stress, fear, and limitations you’re experiencing aren’t the real problem—but rather symptoms of living in a space far too small for who you are in Christ? In this transformative episode of The R7 Christian Marketing Podcast, mentor Rico Magnelli reveals how toxic motivators (Fear, Lust, Anger, Pride) keep believers trapped in mental prisons, unable to access the spacious freedom that is their true identity in Christ. Rico shares the powerful “ice cube” analogy and walks through the progression from confinement to freedom: Learn, Connect, Share, Grow, Impact. This isn’t about trying harder, it’s about discovering who you truly are when you put on the mind of Christ.
Quick Answer: Your Identity Changes Everything
Rico Magnelli, seasoned Christian mentor, has discovered that most believers are living in spaces far too small for their calling. His solution: Understanding that your true identity is found in Christ, not in the toxic motivators of Fear, Lust, Anger, and Pride (FLAP) that the adversary uses to keep you confined. The transformation happens when you embrace salvation and realize the space within which you live and function becomes huge—you move from the ice cube rattling in a glass to the ice cube in the ocean. Same challenges, infinitely larger space. Your identity in Christ means: perfect love instead of fear, freedom instead of lust, peace instead of anger, and humility instead of pride. When you put on the mind of Christ and the righteousness of God, you learn, connect, share, grow, and impact—reflecting His light rather than absorbing the world’s negativity.
Who is Rico Magnelli?
Rico Magnelli is a Christian mentor, teacher, and devoted follower of Jesus Christ who specializes in helping believers discover and live in their true identity in Christ. He:
- Leads transformative workshops focused on spiritual freedom and practical discipleship
- Works closely with Christian entrepreneurs, leaders, and families
- Brings deep biblical insight combined with practical application
- Has a heart for seeing believers walk in the fullness of what Christ has for them
- Focuses on helping people transition from intellectual Christianity to heart-centered faith
His mission: Helping Christians recognize the mental prisons they’ve decorated and helping them step into the spacious freedom that is their identity in Christ.
Why Are You Living in Too Small of a Space?
Rico delivers a startling diagnosis: “People are stressed because they’re living in too small of a space. That’s why they’re hopeless and they’re stressed out.”
The identity crisis
When you don’t understand your identity in Christ, you:
- Accept confinement as normal
- Believe the glass is all there is
- Make noise in your small space (stress, anxiety, fear)
- Can’t see the larger reality available to you
- Live compressed on all sides with pressure
The revelation: “Once you embrace salvation, the space within which you live and function is huge, and you’re no longer compressed on all sides with pressure because you’re living in a much larger space—that larger eternity. And that comes through being in Christ.”
What is the Ice Cube Analogy?
Rico shares one of the most powerful illustrations about identity in Christ:
“The illustration is the ice cube in the glass. It’s like the stress is in a small space in your mind, and it makes a lot of noise. But once you take that ice cube and you put it in a larger container, it doesn’t do that anymore.”
Understanding the analogy
The ice cube: Your problems, challenges, circumstances—they don’t change
The glass: Living according to your limited human perspective, trapped by toxic motivators, confined to what you can see and control
The ocean: Your identity in Christ—the vast, spacious reality of living in His kingdom, with eternity brought into your day
The transformation
The same challenges that made you stressed and hopeless in the glass become manageable in the ocean. Why? Because the context has changed. You’re no longer defined by your limitations but by whose you are.
Rico’s words: “That’s like bringing eternity into your day. Once you embrace salvation, the space within which you live and function is huge.”
What Are the Four Toxic Motivators Stealing Your Identity?
The FLAP framework identifies four primary toxic motivators that keep you from living in your true identity in Christ:
F – Fear (Instead of Love)
Not healthy caution, but crippling fear that makes you forget who your Father is and what He’s promised.
Biblical truth: Perfect love casts out fear (1 John 4:18). Fear and love are like oil and water—they cannot coexist. When you know your identity as God’s beloved child, fear loses its power.
Identity shift: From “I’m afraid of what might happen” to “I am loved by the One who holds all things”
L – Lust (Instead of Freedom)
Lust for possessions, validation, titles, self-worth through external means—constantly craving more because you don’t know who you are in Christ.
Biblical truth: You lose your freedom and become subject to the tyranny of things. But in Christ, you’re already complete, already approved, already enough.
Identity shift: From “I need this to be somebody” to “I am free in Christ, lacking nothing”
A – Anger (Instead of Peace)
Anger that controls your reactions because circumstances threaten the small space you’re trying to protect.
Biblical truth: The tranquility that comes from God on the inside brings peace. When you know you’re living in the ocean, not the glass, threats to your temporary circumstances don’t shake your core identity.
Identity shift: From “I must defend and protect” to “I am at peace because God is in control”
P – Pride (Instead of Humility)
The inability to ask for help because you believe you must prove your worth through self-sufficiency.
Biblical truth: Pride comes before a fall. But when you understand your identity is in Christ, not in your accomplishments, you can be humble because you have nothing to prove.
Identity shift: From “I can do it all myself” to “By the grace of God, I am what I am”
What Are the Mental Prisons We Decorate?
According to Rico: “People start putting up pictures and paint the walls in their little mental prison. They get comfortable in there. But really, what they need to do is recognize that they’re being held back. They’re incarcerated.”
The comfort of false identity
Many believers become so accustomed to living in the glass that they:
- Stop recognizing it as confinement
- Decorate their limitations
- Accept stress as normal
- Resist those who point out there’s more
- Build their identity around their prison rather than Christ
The problem: You’ve made your small space comfortable enough that you don’t realize you’re missing the ocean.
The role of loved ones
“Sometimes those that love you may point something out to you that you’re not necessarily registering because you’ve become accustomed to it. That is a real deal right there.”
The question: Are you ready for unsolicited advice from people who can see that you’re living beneath your identity in Christ?
Why You Can’t Discover Your Identity Alone
One of Rico’s most critical warnings: “Many people make this mistake: they deep dive into their soul, they go soul searching, and they drown.”
The labyrinth of self-discovery
The fatal flaw: “They drown because they don’t go in with Jesus Christ. They go by themselves.”
Your inner world is like a labyrinth. If you try to discover your identity through self-exploration alone—without Jesus Christ as your guide—you’ll get lost. This is what Paul describes in Romans: trying to figure it out on your own and being unable to produce the right results.
The proper approach to identity
Being aware that something is not right is the first step. But self-awareness alone won’t reveal your true identity. You need:
- Jesus as your guide through the discovery process
- The light to show you who you really are in Him
- Time for truth to penetrate beyond your intellect
- Trusted voices who see you through God’s eyes
Rico’s insight: “We have to allow the light to show us as we dive deep into your own soul and your own problems.”
How Do You Listen with Your Heart, Not Just Your Ears?
Rico emphasizes that discovering your identity in Christ requires a different kind of listening:
“There’s a thing about listening. And I don’t mean with these two things here. I mean with your heart. There’s something about it that easily makes it transition into a better life for you and me.”
Beyond intellectual knowledge
As James teaches: be slow to speak, slow to wrath. But this isn’t just about controlling your words—it’s about receiving truth about your identity at a heart level, not just an intellectual level.
The trap of intellectualizing identity: “Sometimes pride is one of the four you mentioned. We resist that. We don’t listen to our heart. We try to intellectualize everything, and that’s not a good way to go.”
What heart-listening produces
When you listen with your heart about who you are in Christ:
- Truth penetrates deeper than theological knowledge
- Identity transformation happens faster than information accumulation
- You receive what your intellect might resist
- God can bypass your mental defenses
- You begin to actually believe what Scripture says about you
The shift: From knowing about your identity in Christ to knowing your identity in Christ.
What Does Your Identity in Christ Actually Look Like?
Rico describes the transformation that happens when you move from the glass to the ocean:
The awakening moment
“Oh my gosh, the world of God is awesome. The room is big. I’m less stressed. I have all these options.”
This is the moment you realize: “When you’re in Christ, it’s less stress and more freedom. You’re in the water and it’s just limitless.”
No walls, infinite options
“If you’re in a room with one way out, that’s not it. God has no walls. That’s free. That’s extremely freeing.”
Putting on your new identity
The decision to follow Jesus Christ means: “You put on the mind of Christ. You put on the righteousness of God.”
This isn’t positive thinking or self-improvement. This is putting on a completely new identity—one that’s been yours all along in Christ, but you’ve been living too small to access it.
What is the Five-Stage Identity Transformation?
Rico outlines the progression once you’ve embraced your identity in Christ:
1. Learn
“That’s part of the learning process.”
You begin to understand:
- Who you are in Christ (beloved, approved, complete)
- What’s available to you (all spiritual blessings, His power, His promises)
- How to walk in this new spacious freedom
- The difference between the glass and the ocean
Important: This isn’t instantaneous—it’s a journey of discovery and growth.
2. Connect
“The next thing is to connect with people. Once you connect with people, you begin to share what you’re learning.”
Your identity in Christ is meant to be lived in community. You’re part of the body of Christ. Connection with other believers is essential because:
- They reflect back to you who you are in Him
- They journey with you from glass to ocean
- They help you stay accountable to your true identity
- They celebrate your transformation
3. Share
“When you start sharing what you’re learning, it actually multiplies within you.”
This is the unique property of spiritual truth—it’s not like sharing information. When you share what you’re discovering about your identity in Christ:
- It increases your capacity to receive more from God
- It builds something within you
- It does something transformative in your heart
- It multiplies rather than depletes
Why sharing is different: “Information didn’t come from this earth. It came from God. So once you start sharing it, it improves and increases your capacity to receive more from God.”
4. Grow
“When you grow, life becomes dynamic. You are not afraid of change. You welcome positive godly change in your life and you start encouraging that in others. You start making a difference.”
Living in your identity in Christ means:
- No longer being static or stuck in the glass
- Welcoming positive change
- Becoming a catalyst for transformation in others
- Making an impact from the ocean, not the glass
5. Impact
“When you’re around people, you don’t blend in. You actually start making a positive impact in your sphere of influence, in your community, and sometimes in society.”
Why? “Because it’s not you. It’s Christ in you. Like Paul said, by the grace of God, I am what I am.”
The transformation: “You don’t necessarily absorb their negativity. You actually reflect light, and you redirect them back to God. You reconcile them back. It’s amazing.”
This is the full expression of your identity in Christ—you become a light-reflector, not a negativity-absorber.
Whose Voice Defines Your Identity?
Rico brings a sobering perspective on what’s competing for your identity:
“Who’s moving the fear, the lust, the anger, the pride? Is it the squirrels and the chickens and the cows and the grass? No. There’s systems designed to move it. And those have unlimited resources—figuratively speaking—because they promote it.”
The marketing of false identity
The world markets:
- Fear-based identity: You are what you’re afraid of losing
- Lust-driven identity: You are what you possess or achieve
- Anger-fueled identity: You are your grievances and resentments
- Pride-centered identity: You are your accomplishments and self-sufficiency
These aren’t accidents—they’re deliberate systems with massive resources.
The contrast: The body of Christ promotes your true identity—who you are in Christ.
The critical question about identity
Rico asks himself (and us): “Do I believe that the systems of this world, which Satan offered to Christ, are they more powerful than what God said? And honestly, I’ve had that conversation with God many times because I get afraid. Isn’t God enough?”
The answer: “He is enough. He is enough.”
What this means for your identity: The world’s definition of who you are is not more powerful than God’s definition of who you are. He is enough to establish, maintain, and defend your true identity.
What Does “By the Grace of God, I Am What I Am” Really Mean?
Paul’s declaration in 1 Corinthians 15:10 is central to understanding identity in Christ:
“By the grace of God, I am what I am.”
Not self-made identity
This isn’t: “By my effort, intelligence, talent, or achievement, I am what I am.”
Not circumstance-based identity
This isn’t: “By my circumstances, history, or experiences, I am what I am.”
Grace-based identity
This is: “Everything I am is because of God’s grace. My identity is rooted in Him, not in me.”
Rico’s application: When you’re making an impact, “it’s not you. It’s Christ in you.”
Living from this identity
When you understand “by the grace of God, I am what I am,” you:
- Stop trying to prove your worth
- Stop defending your small space
- Stop building your identity on shifting sand
- Start living from who you already are in Christ
- Start reflecting His light instead of absorbing the world’s darkness
How Do You Practice Living in Your Identity?
Rico and Dave close with practical guidance for those discovering their identity in Christ:
Start with humility and thankfulness
“If you’re listening and you don’t know where to go or what to do, use where you’re at right now. Show that humility right now about where you’re at. Be thankful for where you’re at.”
Humility is acknowledging: “I don’t have to pretend I’ve arrived. My identity is secure in Christ regardless of where I am in the journey.”
The practice of thankfulness
Dave shares his go-to practice: “When I pray, I always start with ‘Today I’m thankful for…’ It’s easy to wrap your prayers around that.”
Why this matters for identity:
- Thankfulness reminds you that you’re not the source
- Gratitude combats pride (one of the four toxic motivators)
- It reorients your heart toward who God is and who you are in Him
- It pulls you out of the glass and reminds you of the ocean
For those fighting the fight
“If you’re out there promoting Jesus and faith and giving, love, forgiveness—you’re fighting the fight because we need more of you. We need more of you out there.”
Your identity in Christ makes you a warrior, not a victim. You’re fighting from victory, not for victory. The fight is worth it because you know whose you are.
Key Takeaways: Living in Your Identity in Christ
- You’re living in too small of a space – Most believers are stressed because they haven’t embraced the spacious freedom of their identity in Christ
- The ice cube analogy – Same challenges, different container; move from the glass to the ocean
- Toxic motivators steal identity – Fear, Lust, Anger, Pride (FLAP) keep you confined to the glass
- Don’t soul-search alone – You need Jesus as your guide to discover who you are in Him
- Listen with your heart – Identity transformation happens deeper than intellectual knowledge
- Recognize your mental prison – You may have decorated it so well you don’t realize you’re confined
- Put on the mind of Christ – Your identity shift comes from putting on His righteousness
- Follow the progression – Learn, Connect, Share, Grow, Impact
- By the grace of God, I am what I am – Your identity is rooted in His grace, not your performance
- You’re a light-reflector, not a negativity-absorber – This is the full expression of your identity in Christ
- God is enough – The world’s systems cannot define you more powerfully than God does
- Practice thankfulness – It anchors you in your true identity when you’re struggling
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How do I know if I’m living in the “glass” instead of the “ocean”?
A: Rico says you’ll feel stressed, hopeless, and compressed on all sides. You’ll make a lot of noise (anxiety, fear, striving) in a small space. When you’re living in your identity in Christ, you experience the same challenges but with less stress and more freedom because the space within which you function is huge.
Q: What if I intellectually know my identity in Christ but don’t feel it?
A: This is exactly what Rico warns about. You need to listen with your heart, not just your ears or intellect. Stop trying to intellectualize everything. Let the light show you who you are through Jesus, not through self-discovery alone.
Q: How long does it take to move from the glass to the ocean?
A: Rico emphasizes it’s a learning process. You embrace salvation (the decision), then you learn, connect, share, grow, and impact (the progression). It’s not instantaneous, but the moment you put on the mind of Christ and the righteousness of God, the space begins to expand.
Q: What if the toxic motivators (FLAP) still affect me even though I’m a Christian?
A: This is normal and why Rico is teaching about them. Being a Christian doesn’t make you immune—it gives you the solution. When Fear arises, remember perfect love casts it out. When Lust tempts, remember you’re free in Christ. When Anger flares, pursue peace. When Pride emerges, practice humility. Your identity in Christ is the antidote.
Q: How do I handle loved ones who point out that I’m living in a “mental prison”?
A: Rico says this is “a real deal” because people often can’t see what they’ve become accustomed to. Ask yourself: Am I ready for unsolicited advice or criticism? The people who love you can often see you’re living beneath your identity in Christ when you can’t see it yourself.
Q: What does it practically mean to “put on the mind of Christ”?
A: It means adopting His perspective on who you are, what’s possible, and what matters. You move from “I’m in a room with one way out” to “God has no walls.” You put on His righteousness instead of trying to earn your own. You begin to think and live from the ocean, not the glass.
Q: How do I know if I’m absorbing negativity or reflecting light?
A: Rico says when you’re living in your identity in Christ, “you don’t necessarily absorb their negativity. You actually reflect light, and you redirect them back to God.” If you find yourself constantly drained, discouraged, and blending in, you’re absorbing. If you’re making a positive impact and reconciling others back to God, you’re reflecting.
The R7 process helps Christian leaders and marketers discover their purpose and build actionable strategy around their calling. If you’re ready to move from the glass to the ocean—to live in the spacious freedom of your true identity in Christ instead of the confined stress of toxic motivators—tune in to The R7 Christian Marketing Podcast for more faith-driven conversations about discovering who you really are in Him.
Remember: Eagles don’t seek approval. They just fly. What’s keeping you grounded?
🎧 Follow The R7 Christian Marketing Podcast 🎧
► Website: https://www.misgood.com
► YouTube: @TheMisGood
► Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/36LY0LDldVovgiXKGaFtjr?si=474e8096d7f645a5
► Apple Music: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-r7-podcast/id1796027976
Follow Us on Social Media!
►Facebook: /themisgood
►Instagram: /misgoodagency
►TikTok: @m_is_good_
Buy Dave’s Book “Vision Wins”
►Amazon: https://amzn.to/3SQPM6Q

